Dave Marquard
← Writing
ad tech

AAMP vs. AdCP is a fight over the order form. The important part is where the bidder runs.

Both agentic ad standards hand the finished deal to a DSP; the piece that could change who sits in the buy path is ARTF, which runs buying logic inside the exchange.

For most of this year, agentic advertising has been covered as a “standards war.” IAB Tech Lab has AAMP, its umbrella of agent protocols, reference agents and an agent registry. AgenticAdvertising.org, the independent group that grew out of Scope3’s coalition with Yahoo, PubMatic and others, has AdCP, which announced general availability of v3.2 at the end of September. Tech Lab COO Shailley Singh has argued the two overlap on 13 functions, and AdCP’s own docs concede the overlap in scope, “with different primitives.” Neither camp claims they’re complementary layers.

Most of the coverage since has scored the two specs against each other, feature by feature. I think that misses where the bigger change is. Both protocols mostly automate the same thing: a direct deal that agents negotiate over APIs instead of people over email and spreadsheets. Either way, it ends with a deal ID handed to a DSP. The piece that could change who sits in the buy path is a less glamorous part of Tech Lab’s stack called ARTF, which lets buying logic run inside the exchange itself.

Two protocols, one order form

Strip away the branding and the two workflows look a lot alike. A buyer agent sends a brief. A seller agent answers with proposals. The agents negotiate inside limits a person set, a person approves, and the order gets booked. In AAMP’s reference flow, the booked order becomes an OpenDirect order, the deal ID is activated in a DSP, and delivery runs over OpenRTB the way it does today. AdCP runs over MCP and A2A with its own task names (get_signals, create_media_buy, etc), but a negotiated AdCP buy still clears as OpenRTB and VAST underneath.

That’s useful work. Anyone who has run a direct-sold CTV business knows how much of the day goes to RFP spreadsheets, avails checks, IO back-and-forth, etc. Agents should take most of that off people’s plates. It’s still an efficiency gain on the existing path, and both camps more or less say so. IAB board chair Alison Levin’s line is that “just because you design a new car, doesn’t mean you need to build a new track.” Adform CTO Jochen Schlosser put the limit more bluntly: today’s agents “can only do rate card fast.”

Which protocol wins that workflow matters a great deal to the companies writing the specs. My guess is it matters much less to everyone else, because either way the result is a faster order form that still feeds a DSP.

Singh’s own framing points the same direction: “MCP is a communication substrate; it does not reconcile their advertising semantics.” The two camps are arguing over vocabulary. Under either one, the deal at the end looks about the same.

The part that moves the buyer

ARTF (the Agentic RTB Framework, out since November 2025) gets the least attention of anything in AAMP, which is odd, because it’s the one piece that changes where the buying happens. It lets a partner package its logic as a container and run it inside an SSP’s or exchange’s infrastructure, in the auction. The host decides which bid request fields the container sees and has the final say on every change it proposes; Index Exchange’s getting-started guide sums it up as “You propose, the host decides.” The container can’t call out to anything except the host. Tech Lab’s pitch is that a partner’s logic runs “without your data ever having to leave it.” The standard matters because the alternative, as Index’s Michael Richardson told VideoWeek this week, is every SSP doing containers its own way, so a partner has to “build your application in six different ways.”

This is already in production. Nano Interactive runs its intent model in a container on Index Exchange’s Index Cloud, deciding in under 5 milliseconds against roughly 100 million classified pages and millions of CTV titles. It reports a CTR lift of more than 30% in early tests against conventional enrichment (a press release, so treat the number as a vendor’s). PubMatic’s Decision Fabric does the same thing on its own platform, running partner models next to PubMatic’s. I wrote about it in June as the point where the SSP became a place where buying logic executes. On PubMatic’s Q3 call, CEO Rajeev Goel said some “very large DSPs” are “quite interested in things like containerized bidding”.

Today these containers mostly hold data vendors and DSP bidders. The more interesting tenant is the buyer. Picture an agency’s strategy (the audience logic, bid shading, frequency rules, the outcome it’s paying for) written with an LLM’s help and deployed as a container into the SSPs that hold the supply it wants. It runs where the impression and the publisher’s data already are. The publisher can let that data shape the bid without ever handing it to the buyer.

That’s the first-party data deal publishers have wanted for a decade: a clean room that sits inside the auction.

That tenant has started to show up. In September, independent agency PMG began a pilot that moves its CTV buying inside Index Exchange, using Bedrock Platform’s containerized DSP. PMG’s Mike Treon told VideoWeek the draw is being able to “decision against the full breadth of what Index has versus maybe what gets filtered to a specific DSP.”

What that does to the DSP

A DSP today bundles a lot: the bidder, the data, optimization, identity, frequency and pacing across exchanges, brand controls, and the credit and clearing that let an agency buy across thousands of publishers on one invoice. Buyer logic running in the SSP pulls the first three out of the bundle. Nick Tong of Mediaplus UK made a version of this argument in VideoWeek: with agents interrogating supply directly, the DSP “may no longer need to be the primary interface between the buyer and the market.”

In an ideal world, that means agencies write their own buying logic, pay SSPs for compute, and get a much shorter path to the publisher. To get there, three things need to be solved.

First, very few agencies can write a bidder today. The whole idea depends on LLMs lowering that bar enough that a trading team can express a strategy as code someone else hosts. At the rate LLMs are improving right now, that looks like a good bet. PubMatic says independent agencies are the fastest early adopters of its Activate buying tools, which fits: they have the most to gain from skipping a DSP fee and the least legacy to protect.

Second, the DSP’s cross-exchange jobs don’t go away. Frequency capping, dedup and budget pacing across SSPs need something that sees all of them, and a container in one exchange sees one. Clearing and credit stay too. Tong is right that those capabilities survive; what I’m less sure of is whether they still need to come bundled with the bidder. That matters to buyers, because plumbing like this sounds like something you pay a flat fee for, not a percentage of your media spend.

Last, the first tenants are the DSPs themselves. The near-term version of this story is the big DSPs moving their own bidders into the SSP for latency and data access, which pulls the DSP closer to supply rather than removing it. Optable’s Andy Sharkey warned this month that agentic buying “could add a new toll at every step.” An SSP that hosts everyone’s logic and takes a percentage of all of it is the same tax with a new name.

What I’m watching

So my read on AAMP vs. AdCP is that the negotiation layer probably ends up shared, or at least bridged. Both camps have every reason to interoperate on the order form, and several AdCP members are SSPs that also implement Tech Lab specs. Some of that is already happening without an announcement. The day after Tech Lab posted its OpenProposal draft, Brian O’Kelley filed four AdCP change proposals citing it, and ideas from them shipped in AdCP’s 3.3 beta. The fight with real money behind it is over who gets to run code in the exchange, and on whose terms.

A few things would tell me which way it’s going:

My bet: by the end of 2027, every holding company will run bidding logic it wrote itself inside an SSP for a real slice of its CTV spend, with no DSP’s bidder in that path. PMG has already moved its buying into the exchange; the step I’m betting on is the agency owning the code that runs there. Which spec its order form used will be a footnote.